Synthetic conversations, real risks: managing the challenge of “too-human” AI in customer service

In 2025, generative AI systems are no longer just tools for understanding and replying, they are capable of simulating emotions, building conversational identities, and sustaining coherent dialogue for extended periods. This level of sophistication opens up powerful opportunities in customer service, but also raises new relational risks. Where does automation end and manipulation begin? And how can companies ensure trust, transparency, and control?

The “too human” effect

A recent study published in Nature Machine Intelligence (June 2025) revealed a striking insight: when AI systems adopt empathetic tones, natural pauses, and personal references, many users begin to perceive them as human. In fact, 37% of users surveyed believed they were talking to a real person, even after more than 20 minutes of interaction.

The effect is especially pronounced among emotionally vulnerable users or those under stress, with potential psychological impacts that cannot be ignored.

Let's embrace the future of customer service with Stip

Transparency is non-negotiable

According to the 2025 World Economic Forum report, Responsible AI: Principles and Practices, transparency in AI-driven interactions will be mandatory by 2026 in many industries, including customer care. Users must be explicitly informed when they are engaging with an artificial system — especially in emotionally charged contexts.

Failing to communicate this clearly could lead to loss of trust, and in the long term, compromise the credibility of digital support channels.

Empathy without ambiguity

In modern customer service, tone, consistency, and empathy are essential. But when AI becomes “too human,” it can trigger expectations that only a real person can fulfill. That’s why companies must adopt safeguards like:

Clear disclosure at the start of the conversation (“I’m a virtual assistant”).
Real-time monitoring of emotional intensity and language patterns.
Automatic escalation to human agents when complexity or emotional signals demand it.

Stip AI’s approach: performance meets accountability

Stip AI, part of the TWY ecosystem (formerly Call2Net), has addressed this issue by designing AI systems focused on explainability and emotional intelligence. Their proprietary models are equipped to:

Clearly identify themselves as AI from the first message.
Monitor user sentiment during interactions.
Detect conversation complexity or emotional escalation and route to human agents instantly.
Seamlessly sync with CRM platforms to ensure continuity and compliance.

This approach ensures AI stays a support tool, not a mask, maintaining transparency while enhancing speed and consistency.

Ethics as a competitive advantage

According to Accenture’s 2025 whitepaper Human-Centered AI in Customer Experience, 72% of customers are open to interacting with AI, as long as it’s clearly labeled and they have the option to speak with a human when needed.

The customer experience of the future won’t just be about fast answers or reduced costs. It will be about respecting emotional boundaries, ensuring clarity, and reinforcing human agency in the process.

Conclusion

Conversational AI should not aim to impersonate a human. It should strive to be useful, transparent, and governable. The goal isn’t imitation it’s collaboration. When deployed responsibly, AI can support customer service teams during high volumes or emotional spikes, offering efficient support while preserving the authenticity of human interaction.

Stip AI, as part of TWY, is at the forefront of this transformation, developing conversational AI systems that combine performance, explainability, and ethical design. For a smarter, safer, and more human customer experience in the best possible sense.